Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Montgomery County, IN & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Montgomery County, IN

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 25.26%
Liberty Mutual A 8.07%
Nationwide A+ 7%
GEICO A++ 3.66%
Travelers A++ 2.94%

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Montgomery County, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Joe Richardson 2712 E MAIN ST
46168
317-707-5018
Email:jorichardson@geico.com
Tara Egglinger 427 E Main Attica
47918

Email:taegglinger@geico.com

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Montgomery County, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Andrew J Vanacore Ins Agency Inc 1206 N Lincoln Rd
47872
765-569-6651
Reid Insurance Group Inc 223 S West St # 100
46052
(765) 482-4066
Email:customerservice@reidinsurance.biz
Shofner Lynch & Shulse Llc 3535 Clarks Creek Road
46168
Txu Employees 8402 E 116Th Street
46038
Littleton Insurance Group 7780 N MICHIGAN RD STE C
46268
317-334-1162
Weston Ins Agency Llc 429 N Pennsylvania St #202
www.westoninsagency.com 46204

Email:BRET@WESTONINSAGENCY.COM
Tag-Foothills 650 E. Drive, Suite 400
46032
Bayless Insurance Agency Inc 8823 Madison Ave
baylessinsurance.com 46227-6568
317-888-9747
Email:jessica@baylessinsurance.com
Kansas Preferred Ins Group Llc 217 1/2 W WILLIAMS
www.kpigroup.net 61832
217-709-0678
Email:keith@kpigroup.net
Combined Ins Services Llc 14028 Britton Park Rd
www.combined-ins.com 46038-4463
317-774-9000
Email:tcook.combi06@insuremail.net

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Montgomery County, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Matthew Oliver 1315 S Lebanon St
46052-2793
(765) 484-8522
David R Mcgrath 2409 S 18th St
47909
(765) 477-0303
Hannah Ostrander 342 Massachusetts Ave
46204
(317) 687-0777
Shahla E. Mciver 3830 W 96th Street
46268
Shaun Smith Lutcf 5140 S Madison, Ste 2
46227
Scott Vaught 111 Congressional Blvd Suite 100
46032
Scott Weinschenk Lutcf 30 S Peru Street
46034
S. Therese Stanford 915 E Main Street
61832
Claudia M. Perez Luctf 7423 E 82nd St
46256-1407
317-849-4119
Timothy Cottrill 3830 Carwinion Way
46032

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Montgomery County, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Nicole Page 204 N COLLEGE AVE
46135
(765) 653-2641
Ted Ferry 34 N Monroe St
www.tedferry.com 47993
Erik Krauss 1236 W 86th St
46260
(317) 218-3220
Staci Waters 8900 Keystone Crossing, Suite 300
www.myagentstaci.com 46240
Allan Davis Jr 9546 Allisonville Rd Ste 107
www.allandavisjr.com 46250-1223
317-570-0854
Phyllis Mitchell 14701 CUMBERLAND RD STE 108
46060
(317) 776-4095
Christy Winter 3224 S Lafountain St
www.agentwinter.com 46902-3714
765-453-0311
Joe Runion 5004 W 16TH STREET
46224
317-248-0070
Craig Duncan 817 S Washington ST
www.cduncan.net 47933-3546
765-359-1550
John Cole 300 E ALTO RD
www.jcoleismyagent.com 46902
765-453-6704

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Montgomery County, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Knippenberg Insurance And Financial Services Inc CIRCLE TOWER BLDG 55 MONUMENT CIR STE 500
46204
317-639-5679
Brian Maxwell 4745 Statesmen Dr Ste D
46250-5649
317-842-6807
Cothran Insurance 8345 Little Eagle Ct
46234-3819
317-273-9300
Vogel And Moore Inc 3750 Guion Rd
46222
Renea S Rowland 8925 N Meridian St Ste 101
46260
(317) 582-1772
Harrison Insurance Of Texas 14701 Cumberland Rd Ste 180
46060
(317) 386-1370
Timothy L. Kennedy 17 N Vandalia Street
47834
Knippenberg Insurance And Financial Services Inc 1402 NORTH CAPITOL
46202
317-634-7491
Keith Jackson Insurance Agency Inc. 910 N SHADELAND AVE STE E
46219
317-357-2700
Marker Insurance Services 1700 W Smith Valley Rd Ste B-3
46142-1599
(317) 885-8300

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Montgomery County, IN

State FarmGEICOLiberty Mutual
Median Home Value ($) 106,560126,560116,560
Construction year 196019811968
Home Coverage ($) $100000-$125000$150000-$175000$100000-$125000
Total Premium ($) $1038$1138$1008

Montgomery County, IN Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
GEICO upto 21%
Travelers upto 8%
Liberty Mutual upto 15%
Nationwide upto 11%