Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Michigan City, IN & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Michigan City, IN

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 25.26%
Liberty Mutual A 8.07%
Allstate A+ 8.05%
Nationwide A+ 7%
Travelers A++ 2.94%

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Michigan City, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Harvest Ins Agency Inc 10917 Miami St
www.harvestinsurance.com 46307
(219) 488-2434
Atlantic Insurance Agency 17943 Halsted St
60430-2013
708-798-3550
Wren Insurance Group Inc 3412 W 95Th Street
www.wreninsgrp.com 60805

Email:phillip@wreninsgrp.com
Everett Financial Group Llc 15524 Cicero Ave
www.seminole.greatflorida.com 60452
(708) 687-6200
Clark-Mortenson Agency Inc 4770 N Milwauke Ave
60630-3629
773-282-5422
Alternatives Insurance Agency 6006 159th St Bldg D Unit 1E
60452-2904
708-687-0072
Hansen Insurance Agency 829 Lincolnway
46383
(219) 462-7436
Paul F Tilly Agency Llc 200 E RANDOLPH ST FL 15
www.tillyagency.com 60601
(312) 381-5300
Email:service@tillyagency.com
Broadway Insurance Agency 5275 Broadway
www.broadwayins.com 46410-1552
219-981-3111
Email:vincent@broadwayins.com
America Insurance Brokers Inc 4810 W 83rd St
www.goaib.com 60459-2719
708-425-2886
Email:sales@goaib.com

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Michigan City, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Alicia Ondik Agency 3430 Hollywood Rd
49085-9551
269-429-5500
David C. Matthews Jr. Inc. 2330 Wicker Avenue
46375-2810
219-322-4447
Wayne P Johnson 5550 N Elston Ave
60630
Christopher T Sniscak Agency 6824 S Pulaski Rd
60629-4121
773-585-6789
Scott E Sechler 9105a Indianapolis Blvd # 300
46322
Grove F&A Inc 1152 Wilmette Ave
60091
(847) 251-6464
Grillo & Associates Inc 719 Ship St
49085
(269) 983-0070
James A Dorsey 3525 WEST PETERSON AVE
60659
312-539-4242
Sunrise Insurance Group Inc 205 Pennsylvania Ave
49047
Emily Cobb Morris 612 Ridge Rd
46321
(219) 836-0515

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Michigan City, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Trevor Waling 618 East Third St
46342
Paramjit Kaur 911 RIDGE RD
46321
(219) 836-8900
Chris Judd 954 W Webster Ave
60614-3623
773-975-9111
Olga Vizir 200 E RANDOLPH ST 13TH FL
60601
(312) 381-1000
Ray Baugher 3790 W 79th St
60652
(773) 498-9388
Anica Mckesey Lutcf 245 W Joe Orr Rd
60411-1744
708-755-3000
Chelsey Jones Lutcf 1754 E Market St
46550-9216
574-773-AUTO
Susie Adib 328 S Jefferson St Ste 218
60661
Brandon Rawls 5245 N Central Ave
60630-4656
773-930-4760
Amanda Tarasow 7103 Broadway
46410-3539
219-738-2588

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Michigan City, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Christopher Shirley 10735 S Cicero Ave Ste 201
60453-6211
708-423-7612
Tyler Mcglasson 300 S Wacker #2000
60606
Harbans Soni 3322 N Halsted St
60657
(773) 525-3030
Aisha Ratkewitch 4207 Calumet Ave
46383-2244
219-462-7424
Devery Prince Agency Team 8452 S Stony Island Ave Fl 2
60617
(773) 721-0007
Cheryl R Kirkland 127 S Stewart St
46506-1829
574-546-4422
Ok Agents Alliance 233 S WACKER DR STE 2000
60606
(312) 288-7700
Associated Insurance Centers 1011 Broadway St
49120-2762
269-683-2562
Aj Cummings 5724 S Pulaski Rd
60629-4435
773-582-7070
Lyn Cheslick 1631 S MICHIGAN AVE STE 103
60616
312-789-8010

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Michigan City, IN

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Alex Aguado 17659 Oak Park Ave
www.alexaguado.com 60477-3921
708-429-MARK
Darrell Foss 9002 Cline Avenue
www.darrellfoss.com 46322
219-923-3030
Bob Palenshus 908 Main St Ste 1
www.bobpinsurance.com 49085-1490
269-983-5447
Laura Ash 16539 S OAK PARK AVE
www.laura-ash.com 60477
708-444-4100
Lisa Ramlow 2925 HIGHWAY AVENUE
www.lisajramlow.com 46322
219-838-1400
Mary Lowe 5550 N Elston Avenue
60630
Amy Oden-Bitner 9701 S Commercal Ave
www.amyoden-bitner.com 60617-5404
773-221-9810
Ray Adkins Iii 15475 S Park Ave
60473
(708) 331-6266
Earl Timmons 5533 W 109th St Ste 205
60453
(708) 636-8800
Tim Slesk 54101 Ironwood Road
46635

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Michigan City, IN

State FarmLiberty MutualAllstate
Median Home Value ($) 80,10080,10080,100
Construction year 194519411969
Home Coverage ($) $100000-$125000$100000-$125000$125000-$150000
Total Premium ($) $1163$1194$1177

Michigan City, IN Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Travelers upto 7%
Nationwide upto 9%
Liberty Mutual upto 15%
Allstate upto 15%