Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Columbus, IN & compare the best quotes from them.
| Home Insurance Company | A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating | Homeowners Insurance Market share |
|---|---|---|
| State Farm | A | 25.26% |
| nationwide | A+ | 8.2% |
| Liberty Mutual | A | 8.07% |
| Nationwide | A+ | 7% |
| Erie | A+ | 5.59% |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| John Dorsey | 355 Smith Road 47240 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claudia M. Perez Luctf | 7423 E 82nd St 46256-1407 |
317-849-4119 | |
| Shaun Smith Lutcf | 5140 S Madison, Ste 2 46227 |
||
| Hannah Ostrander | 342 Massachusetts Ave 46204 |
(317) 687-0777 | |
| Damon Yturralde | 444 S College Avenue 47403-1513 |
812-339-5529 | |
| Moira H Mcenroe | 355 INDIANA AVE STE 200 46204 |
317-464-5000 | |
| Nicole Lieder | 325 W MAIN ST STE 1 47240 |
(812) 663-5151 | |
| Ellie Thomas | 2611 Central Ave Ste 2 47201 |
(812) 376-8396 | |
| Bri Miller | 5040 W Us 52 Ste A 46163-8637 |
317-861-2400 | |
| Alex Mullen | 506 E Main St 47250-3647 |
812-265-6601 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Recker | 6319 E US HWY 36 STE 100 46123 |
317-718-1747 | |
| Tyler Bullington | 1100 State Rd 39 Bypass www.tylerbullington.com 46151 |
||
| Brandon Hazel | 6437 Rucker Rd Ste B 46220-4868 |
317-253-4300 | |
| Cliff Mueller | 1000 N State St 47265-7476 |
812-346-9700 | |
| Mike Speten | 215 W MAIN ST www.mikespeten.com 47250 |
812-265-2965 | |
| Doug Mercer | 8202 US 31 S www.dougmercer.com 46227 |
(317) 851-5797 | |
| John Geitner | 8604 Allisonville Road, Suite 210 46250 |
||
| Debbie Drury | 8033 S Meridian St www.debbiedrury.com 46217 |
(317) 881-0412 | |
| Tino Amaya | 45 West Washington Indianapolis 46176 |
||
| Len Sieckman | 770 E MORGAN ST 47460 |
812-829-6133 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Michael Tobash | 2020 South State Road 135 Suite 203 46143 |
1-317-535-5644 | |
| Knippenberg Ins & Fin Srv Inc | 300 N MERIDIAN STE 1700 46204 |
317-841-3309 | |
| Knippenberg Ins & Fin Srv Inc | 429 N PENNSYLVANIA STREET SUITE 202 46204 |
317-236-6158 | |
| John A Peterson Jr | 1229 W MAIN ST 46140 |
317-462-7292 | |
| Vogel And Moore Inc | 3750 Guion Rd 46222 |
||
| Knippenberg Insurance And Financial Services Inc | 1402 NORTH CAPITOL 46202 |
317-634-7491 | |
| Knippenberg Ins & Fin Srv Inc | 355 INDIANA AVE STE 200 46204 |
317-464-5000 | |
| Jessup Insurance Agency Inc | 500 E TIPTON ST 47274 |
812-522-2221 | |
| Bentley Insurance Inc. | 1625 O St 47421-4116 |
812-279-6601 | |
| Stephen J Balkun | 459 S Landmark Ave 47403 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blackwater Insurance Group | 920 W Kathys Way Ste F 47240-3413 |
812-663-6626 | |
| Total Insurance Agency | 8250 Haverstick Rd Ste 145 8250 Haverstick Rd Ste 145 46240 |
||
| Renz Insurance Agency Inc | 920 N Shadeland Ave Ste G1a 46219 |
(317) 351-6933 | |
| Alliance Insurance Group | 859 Riverside Dr Ste 11 46142-4147 |
317-882-7995 | |
| Midwest Advantage Insurance & Financial | 4150 Lafayette Rd Ste I 46254 |
(855) 539-2333 | |
| Forbes Insurance Agency Llc | 4 Village Rd PO Box 205 47006 |
(812) 934-3209 | |
| Bradley H Winslow | 2308 E Main St 46168-2733 |
317-839-3322 | |
| Smith-Keats Agency | 122 North Franklin St www.smithkeatsagency.com 47240 |
||
| Abp Insurance Agency Inc. | 2702 W 71st St 46268-2347 |
317-872-7761 | |
| Archer Insurance | 245 Morton Ave 46151-2471 |
765-342-3353 |
| Liberty Mutual | State Farm | nationwide | |
| Median Home Value ($) | 130,950 | 130,950 | 150,950 |
| Construction year | 1949 | 1942 | 1989 |
| Home Coverage ($) | $350000-$400000 | $250000-$300000 | $300000-$350000 |
| Total Premium ($) | $2100 | $1182 | $1787 |
| Home Insurance Company | Multi Policy Discount (%) |
|---|---|
| Liberty Mutual | upto 18% |
| Nationwide | upto 9% |
| Erie | upto 17% |